Advertisements
Advertisements
I understand what the person in the video is trying to get across, but I'm rather miffed that this group wasn't more careful with their language, especially given how much distortion this issue seems to get as it is.
Advertisements
L4R please do...
...the sheer damage that type of mystical thinking can create...
will be back to the blank slate theory in no time...
...adoptees don't need to know they were adopted because they are our biological kids now...
good grief...
D
"Adoptive parents become the biological parents through connection. We change their biology."
They wish.
This is a variant of the old view of yesteryear, where adoptive parents feel entitled to everything, first parents are scrubbed from the planet, and adopted individuals are expected to live 'as if born to' etc etc.
Why can't the child simply be loved for EXACTLY who they are?
Why is the ability to change their biology so important to the adoptive parents? Yuk.
"So sometimes parents who have adopted kids or taken them into foster care come to me and say, well, I'm not the biological parent. And I quickly say to them, you know something? The relationship experiences you're providing for your child are influencing the biology of the brain. The kinds of ways we communicate with our child, the environment that we create, all those things literally shape the structure of the brain. And I don't know anything more biological than that. So you are, I say to them, the biological parent. Because you're shaping the biology of your child's brain." - Dr. Daniel Siegel"
Sooooo....my stepmother was really my biological parent too? And my dog? I loved that dog. And my neighbour? She was very important to me - I spent many evenings round at hers after school. What about my teachers at school? They were very influential, I probably spent more conscious time with them than with my parents.
This stuff is just mush, aimed at telling aparents what they most want to hear.
However, its attempts to minimise, even dismiss, the actual and unique biological connection between an individual and their original family is disgraceful and deceitful.
It is entirely self-serving, and yells 'conditional love'.
Advertisements
"So sometimes parents who have adopted kids or taken them into foster care come to me and say, well, I'm not the biological parent. And I quickly say to them, you know something? The relationship experiences you're providing for your child are influencing the biology of the brain. The kinds of ways we communicate with our child, the environment that we create, all those things literally shape the structure of the brain. And I don't know anything more biological than that. So you are, I say to them, the biological parent. Because you're shaping the biology of your child's brain." - Dr. Daniel Siegel"
Sooooo....my stepmother was really my biological parent too? And my dog? I loved that dog. And my neighbour? She was very important to me - I spent many evenings round at hers after school. What about my teachers at school? They were very influential, I probably spent more conscious time with them than with my parents.
This stuff is just mush, aimed at telling aparents what they most want to hear.
However, its attempts to minimise, even dismiss, the actual and unique biological connection between an individual and their original family is disgraceful and deceitful.
It is entirely self-serving, and yells 'conditional love'.
sylvieboots
Sooooo....my stepmother was really my biological parent too? And my dog? I loved that dog. And my neighbour? She was very important to me - I spent many evenings round at hers after school. What about my teachers at school? They were very influential, I probably spent more conscious time with them than with my parents.
This stuff is just mush, aimed at telling aparents what they most want to hear.
However, its attempts to minimise, even dismiss, the actual and unique biological connection between an individual and their original family is disgraceful and deceitful.
It is entirely self-serving, and yells 'conditional love'.
I agree.
I hope that doesn't mean my husband is my biological husband, or even worse, biological parent! I have lived with him as family for far longer than anyone else on the planet.
If that's what it takes to create a situation where I can feel like a real biological parent, not just an adoptive parent... or to erase my original biological family so my adoptive family can be my most important biological family, on paper and in mind/heart...
count me out.
I'm in the camp of nature and nurture are equally important in shaping who I am.
BethVA62
I'm in the camp of nature and nurture are equally important in shaping who I am.
I agree (although I would say nurture/environment rather than just nurture by itself)
I've said this earlier but to me the most telling word in the sentence as quoted in the original post:
"Adoptive parents become the biological parents through connection. We change their biology."
was the word THE. It is amazing what the difference the word "the" can make in a sentence.
It is similar to the "real" statements - "I am a real parent" compared with "I am the real parent". Sentence one states a stand alone fact - if one is parenting a child, they are a real parent - this is regardless of whether other parents are in the picture or not. Sentence two is making it into more of a competition eg "I am the real parent, not THEM" - it is pitting oneself against another.
Advertisements
This is absolute garbage and untrue. As an adoptee, I take offense to this because not only is it a desire and nothing more but it's degrading to one's lineage. I can also attest that not all of us (and more than you think) did not have happy childhoods. I was abused by my adoptive parents in every way. Both were alcoholics and the adoptive mother is a sociopath. I'm 39 years old and she was so abusive, I was brainwashed by her into my 30s.
This quote is apparently attributable to Dr. Karyn Purvis, Director of Texas Christian University's Institute of Child Development:
"Adoptive parents become the biological parents through connection. We change their biology."