Advertisements
Advertisements
While there may not be a lot of research yet, it is starting to happen.
Share with us your own personal stories of GLBT Families.
[url]http://www.colage.org/research/facts.html[/url]
Goshwe wouldn't be so foolhardy as to say what the Truth is about kids with gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender parents. One fact we are sure of: the research is slim.
And another fact: the research has mostly been motivated by family law, which uses the measure of "the best interests of the child" when determining who gets custody of a child in a dispute. Researchers have therefore tried to answer the question, "is having a gay parent worse than having a straight parent on a child's mental health?". The answer is important in custody cases, because a judge's decision could hinge on it. Just to note: of the dozens of studies on kids with gay parents to date, none has shown any noticeable detriment to the child of gay parents. Unfortunately, kids are still being taken away from their parents, solely because their parent is LGBT.
But custody cases are not life: that is to say, research on kids with gay parents hasn't yet shown us the broader picture that we as folks with gay parents live in.
What kinds of long-term differences occur when you grow up in a family where the roles are not clearly delimited by gender?
What benefits, if any, do kids with gay parents get from growing up in, or having access to a supportive gay community?
How much of the experience of kids whose parent(s) come out when they are older (the vast majority), are based on that revelation, and how much on the change in the family structure (like a divorce)?
Do gay parents pass on useful skills for living in a homophobic society like parents of color often pass on useful skills for living in a racist one?
What is the impact on kids who grow up in a gay community when they come out as straight (as most of them do) and no longer, ostensibly, "fit in"?
How has AIDS affected kids with gay dads?
How has breast cancer (which affects lesbians disproportionately) affected kids with lesbian moms?
What are the differences between kids raised in openly gay households versus kids whose parents come out later in life?
And why is there next to no research on kids with transgender or bisexual parents?
For these more in-depth questions, we have no "empirical" answers yet, but kids with gay parents are talking about them, thinking about them, and just living them everyday.
Facts about kids with gay and lesbian parents
In the United States alone, there are millions of people with one or more lesbian, gay, bisexual, and/or transgender (LGBT) parent(s). While research shows that there are no significant developmental differences or negative affects on children of LGBT parents, these youth do report facing significantly more prejudice and discrimination because societal homophobia and transphobia. Youth report that schools are a key place where they face intolerance- from peers, teachers, school administration, and school systems that are affected by the homophobia in our society. According to a 2001 study, students who have LGBT parents experience harassment at the same rate as students who themselves are gay.
As of 1990, 6 million to 14 million children in the United States were living with a gay or lesbian parent. (National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, a service of the U.S. Administration for Children and Families.)
There is absolutely no evidence that children are psychologically or physically harmed in any way by having LGBT parents. There is, however, much evidence that shows that they are not.
People with LGBT parents have the same incidence of homosexuality as the general population, about 10%. No research has ever shown that LGBT parents have any affect on the sexuality of their children. (Patterson, Charlotte J. 1992)
Research claims that children with LGBT parents are exposed to more people of the opposite sex than many kids of straight parents. (Rofes, E.E., 1983, Herdt, 1989)
Studies have shown that people with LGBT parents are more open-minded about a wide variety of things than people with straight parents. (Harris and Turner, 1985/86)
Daughters of lesbians have higher self-esteem than daughters of straight women. Sons are more caring and less aggressive. (Hoeffer, 1981)
On measures of psychosocial well-being, school functioning, and romantic relationships and behaviors, teens with same-sex parents are as well adjusted as their peers with opposite-sex parents. A more important predictor of teens' psychological and social adjustment is the quality of the relationships they have with their parents. (National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health, 2004)
Most "problems" that kids of LGBT parents face actually stem from the challenges of dealing with divorce and the homophobia and transphobia in society rather then the sexual orientation or gender identity of their parents.
The problem with well resoned peer reviewed studies is that the very people who most vehemetly oppose GLBT families don't believe them. They have a pov and nothing can move them from it. "Kids need male AND female parents" and that is that. I am with Lisa from the other thread "I am afraid to leave CA" I just don't want my kid raised around people who think this way.
lisa
Advertisements
I had an interesting discussion about this with a lesbian family that attends the same adoptive families camp that I do every summer. In their books, they really did feel it was harder on their children because their kids were faced with the following issues
1) Having same sex parents
2) Being Transracially adopted
3) Having closed adoptions (none of the GLB families that attend were 'chosen' rather had babies placed with them by agencies when bparents decided not to choose themselves)
Really any of those issues could be big, but the combination? Huge. I know they certainly didnt regret adopting, but they were concerned about what their children would have to face down the road.
Jen
I've thought a lot about this, I guess just because we've entered into the world of adoptive families so we've moved outside of the traditional "round peg" of a family. I have to admit, at first, I thought maybe it wasn't fair to a child to bring him/her into a family that already had to face such prejudice and lack of acceptance. But kids are born into lass than"perfect" families everyday.
I just think a gay or lesbian couple faces some challenges and has to work a little harder sometimes where their child is concerned. The child needs strong, close role models of both sexes. The child needs lots of education at home and love and understanding so he or she can be strong when the questions or ignorang comments come. I totally think it's doable and I wish my kids knew some gay couples with kids so they can see that these families are out there and they can be strong and wonderful.
New Hampshire isn't as liberal as CA but it beats the heck out of SC where I lived for 6 years!!
Martha
MMC66
I totally think it's doable and I wish my kids knew some gay couples with kids so they can see that these families are out there and they can be strong and wonderful.
Martha
Thanks Martha! That statement means a lot to me!
Jensboys
I had an interesting discussion about this with a lesbian family that attends the same adoptive families camp that I do every summer. In their books, they really did feel it was harder on their children because their kids were faced with the following issues
1) Having same sex parents
2) Being Transracially adopted
3) Having closed adoptions (none of the GLB families that attend were 'chosen' rather had babies placed with them by agencies when bparents decided not to choose themselves)
Really any of those issues could be big, but the combination? Huge. I know they certainly didnt regret adopting, but they were concerned about what their children would have to face down the road.
Jen
If we substitute #1 for something like "having parents follow a minority religion" or "having parents with obvious age differences" or "having parents with jobs like garbage collector/ whatever is not considered glamourous" or "having parents who are not rich ENOUGH" or even "having parents who are a bit overweight" the problems would be just as big, if not bigger, to some kids. Yet I find it interesting that few would suggest that those alternate #1 reasons should be grounds for rejecting potential adoptive parents.
Just something to think about.
Advertisements
People interested in this topic might find the HRC study [url=http://www.hrc.org/Template.cfm?Section=Get_Involved1&Template=/ContentManagement/ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=18089]"The Cost of Marriage Inequality to Children and Their Same-Sex Parents"[/url] to be thought-provoking.
I would have GLADLY substituted my abusive heterosexual parents for #1. ;)
I was indeed raised in a heterosexual home but I have NO DOUBT that my life would have been more nurturing and less complicated if I had been raised by a loving same sex couple. I find the idea that a heterosexual family is better, in all cases, as rediculous as saying that families with curly hair make better parents. Love and nurturing seperate the "good" and "bad" in my book. Just my humble opinion which I base on facts of my own childhood.
In respect to the original post I will add that every GLBT family that I have met are very loving, nurturing, and attentive with their children. I have close friends who are mom and mommy to their three sons. I am in awe of their parenting skills and find myself always looking forward to hearing the latest stories about their family and seeing their very generous photoshows. Those boys are so incredibly happy and it is rare that I see them without a smile on their face. Their home swells with love and laughter, and I admit that I find their family unit a source of inspiration in my life.
My husband has a friend (a girl who is grown now) who has two mothers. She is perfectly fine. She went to college at Emory university and is getting married to another of Tony's friend's really soon.
Advertisements