Advertisements
Advertisements
Hello all. I am not really here to adopt - we have 2 daughters (both under 2!) through adoption, and are not *quite* ready for another .... yet!
But I wanted to share a quick summary of our adoptions with you all, because they are both OPEN adoptions (waaaay open) and because I know how scared I was of open adoptions, before I had them!
Just a quick note - when my hubby and started our adoption journey 4-5 years ago, we were completely *against* open adoption. There were many reasons, but foremost amongst them was that we did not want to confuse our children (by keeping birth parents in the picture) and because we wanted it to be clear that *we* were the parents, and no one else. We were very certain about this. But then circumstances intervened (too many to mention here, but there were many and they were all very small) and I (against my will!) read 3 books on open adoption. I was not convinced after reading these books, but I learned 3 things from them (that have proven true, so far):
1- in the adoption triad, *everyone* WINS with open adoption - especially the child! The child will have 2 major problems greatly lessened (problems that every adoptive child has): 1) they will not "fantasize" as much about how their life would have been had they not been placed for adoption, and 2) they will wonder less as to *why* they were placed for adoption (most importantly, they will better understand that it was NOT *their* "fault" and that it was not that they were "unloveable" - because they will see that both the parents and the birth parents love them!)
2- the birth mom (or birth parents) will never wonder what became of their child, and will never wander through grocery stores imagining that their child would look like others they come across. The birth mom will also always have the opportunity to let their child know that they made their decision out of the utmost love for them - that they wanted their child to have the absolute BEST life that they could possibly have! They will always be able to say "I love you"!
3- it is NOT hard on the parents (the adoptive parents) to be a part of open adoption - in fact, it is a huge blessing. The adoptive parents *gain* a whole NEW family! Who wouldn't want that? More love to go around, especially for their child. But also new relationships, especially the "sisterly" bond that happens between adoptive mom and birth mom.
It is such a gift that our daughters can get hugs and kisses from their birth mommies - it does not take away *anything* from me at all (as I feared it would) - it actually makes my heart swell to see my daughters being loved by others - especially someone as treasured (to us) as our birth mommies. My daughters do not doubt who their parents are, and they never will. But they will also recognize the HUGE gift that their birth mommies gave them... in fact, this gift is bigger than any gift my husband or I could ever give to our children. We do not feel threatened by this (as I always feared I would), but rather somehow it makes me so darned HAPPY that my daughters are *this* blessed! I love my girls, and I want the absolute BEST for them, and best for them means that their birth mommies (and daddies, when possible) stay involved.
As to logistics, one of our daughters is from across the country. We never knew that our open adoption would be so VERY open that we would be visiting (most open adoptions stop at phone calls, emails, letters, and photos), but we grew so much in love with birth mommy #1 that we quickly knew we would *want* this. And we do - we visit once or twice a year. Our other daughter is local to us, and we see her birth family every 2-3 weeks. As she grows this will lessen somewhat (there are so many changes right now that we *want* birth family to see!), but they will always be close. They make no demands, and neither do we. We just go with the flow! If we are going to the zoo and would like company, we call them up! And vice versa - it is truly just like "family".
It is just so much EASIER than I ever would have thought it would be, all those years ago. It is also much, much, much more rewarding to me! I never thought that *I* would benefit from open adoption (I thought it was all for the child and especially the birth parents), but I do - very much so. It is also very comfortable - when I am with birth moms I feel as though I am with my younger sisters. And my hubby feels like they are extended family. I imagine that there will always be differences (for example, differences of opinion on how to raise the child, etc.), but just like with family, we will work it out - because we LOVE our new family, and that is what you do with loved ones... you work it out. (Nothing has come up yet, but there *have* to be differences, if I look at it realistically).
Anyway, I have so much more to share about OPEN adoption, and I would love to! Please feel free to email me at SmithAngels@comcast.net and I will be happy to chat with anyone about this. No question is too personal (I don't think - I will let you know if it is, but haven't found one y et, LOL) and I really want to get the word out that this wonderful option exists for us. It truly is an (almost!) gauranteed WIN-WIN-WIN situation for all three parties of the adoption triad! If you wish to see our family adoption website it is here: PLEASE NOTE THAT PARENT PROFILE/DEAR EXPECTANT MOM WEBSITES CANNOT BE POSTED Thanks!!(this is the site that our birth mommies found us on, and fell in love with us over).
Kind regards, Barbie
BarbieSmith
1- in the adoption triad, *everyone* WINS with open adoption - especially the child! The child will have 2 major problems greatly lessened (problems that every adoptive child has): 1) they will not "fantasize" as much about how their life would have been had they not been placed for adoption
I shudder anytime someone describes open adoption as a "*everyone* WINS" situation. Actually, there are losses all around. Open adoption does not remove the losses in adoption, it just gives people more, and true, information by which to process them. For an example, the adult adoptees in open adoptions I know do wonder what their life would be like, they just have more information. For some, this can be painful. For others it is a relief. The difference from a closed adoption adoptee is that they are able to build their fantasies around factual information. The fact remains that they had to be seperated from their first family to get their second one. There is no sugarcoating that.
BarbieSmith
2) they will wonder less as to *why* they were placed for adoption (most importantly, they will better understand that it was NOT *their* "fault" and that it was not that they were "unloveable" - because they will see that both the parents and the birth parents love them!)
This latter is, indeed, one of the benefits. I do have to ask why you think they will wonder less why they were placed for adoption. Again, in the adoptees I know in open adoptions, I have seen the "why" revisited with every new cognitive stage.
Brandy, do you have a different experience?
As a birthmom I also have to say that the losses really overshadow the "wins", especially in the beginning. I had too many people negating my feelings of grief and loss because I "got to know where my child is and see them". That did not take away the ache night after night, nor did it keep me from wondering who my child would have become had I raised him. It also does not make the two weeks surrounding his birthday any easier. 22 years later I still struggle deeply.
I guess I find it really misleading to simplify open adoption in terms of it's benefits. Human relationships are complex and difficult, especially in situations where losses are not clearly defined and everyone's experience is so varied. I speak not only as a birthmom in an open adoption for the past 22.5 years, but also as a professional who has worked with hundreds of people involved in open adoptions. I just is not that simple. Even if it is worth it.
Advertisements
My son is 4 years old; adopted at birth 2 states away. We haven't been to visit bmom family yet, but we plan to maybe even this year.
DS has 3 birth sisters living with bmom--one older and 2 younger. Anyone got thoughts on sibling relationships? I know DS is going to struggle his whole life with "she kept them but gave me away". He'll grapple with that whether we have contact or not. But I would like him to know his sisters, perhaps at the level you would know your cousins who live out of town. I'd like to think by the time he's an adult he could contact them or not as HE chooses.
I have read some other posts on this website about birth-siblings but thought I'd check with you folks, given your experiences.
BarbieSmith,
I'm glad to hear things are going well for you, your children, and the bmoms. :)
I also believe open adoption can be a good experience when all parties can work together for the benifit of a child.
Blessings to you!:flowergift:
Thank you so much for this story!!! My husband and I are strugling with this same thing right now and the more I look into it, the more lickly it seems.
Thank you for this post. My husband are in the process of a very open adoption right now and a lot of what you said calmed some of my worries and fears. :)
Advertisements
BarbieSmith
Just a quick note - when my hubby and started our adoption journey 4-5 years ago, we were completely *against* open adoption.
When we started our adoption journey we were completely *for* open adoption.
BarbieSmith
1- in the adoption triad, *everyone* WINS with open adoption - especially the child!
In my case *my family* did NOT win.
BarbieSmith
2- the birth mom (or birth parents) will never wonder what became of their child,
In my case this is also not true.
BarbieSmith
3- it is NOT hard on the parents (the adoptive parents) to be a part of open adoption
This statement is also not always true - certainly not in my case.
BarbieSmith
It truly is an (almost!) gauranteed WIN-WIN-WIN situation for all three parties of the adoption triad!
I am glad to see that there are such wonderful open adoption experiences out there. This is what I had hoped and dreamed of in our adoption.
But when researching open adoption I hope that the other side of the coin will also be considered.
I had originally not responded to this thread, but it has come back up several times and while Barbie's is a dream come true - an open adoption can also turn against the adoptive family.
In *my* case the birthmother and I signed an open adoption "Agreement." She then turned around and used this same "Agreement" to keep our adoption in jeapardy and to file continuous motions against us.
She does not visit. But 5 and 1/2 years later she is still holding motions against us and is still keeping us in legal turmoil. Again - she does not visit in spite of a court order to do so. But she has cost us tens of thousands of dollars and continuously threatens us with legal motions and a fraud charge.
Yes, my case *may* be an exception. Barbie's case may also be an exception. I don't know.
What I do know is that our open adoption experience has been turned against us and used against us and has hurt my family and my son more than I have the words to express.
Open adoption can be a wonderful journey - but it can also be an unending nightmare.
Please, please consider all possibilities when deciding on open adoption.
I, too, will be glad to respond to any PM.
I believe that what Barbie meant this to refer to was an open adoption that was FINALIZED in which case it has proven true for us.
Kelley
ourdreamcametru
I believe that what Barbie meant this to refer to was an open adoption that was FINALIZED in which case it has proven true for us.
Kelley
Hi Kelly,
I am really glad that open adoptions can and do work out; and that yours worked out as well.
I should add that my adoption was finalized. It was after finalization the birthmother began filing papers to have it reversed and to file other motions against us on numerous and false grounds.
I still believe open adoptions can be best for the child - but there are times in which it is not. And since this has been posted in the "Researching Open Adoption" forum then perhaps those who are researching this area would do well to consider what has happened in both cases.
Thank you for clarifying that Kelly, and again I am always glad to hear when open adoptions do work.
C.S.
Hi Barbie!
We have also had a fabluous open adoption! Our son just turned 1 and our open adoption is quite similar to yours. I have a sisterly bond with our birthmom and we enjoy seeing her outside the realms of the contact agreement. We benfit by having her extended family as well. I feel so blessed each and everyday for the love and trust she has put into us for raising our son! It has been a wonderful relationship that took a lot of baby steps to get to where it is now, but I couldn't imagine our lives withour her in it and I know as my son grows up that she will be there with us. I know not everyone has this type of open adoption, but it is a beautiful thing if everyone is honest and open with each other. Above all my son will have her and us there to answer all his questions and will always know his story!
Advertisements