Advertisements
Advertisements
The story from MSNBC below highlights the vulnerability of Haitian children, and the country as a whole, during this time. I am certain that this article does not tell the whole story, and I'm willing to believe that these folks had good intentions. But the entire plan sounds unethical and poorly thought-out
PORT-AU-PRINCE - Ten American Baptists were being held in the Haitian capital Sunday after trying take 33 children out of Haiti at a time of growing fears over possible child trafficking.
The director of the charity now watching the children told NBC News that one child said she still had parents and was only expecting a brief vacation.
He added that a policeman believed the group was trying to sell the children for $10,000 each, an allegation denied by the church members.
"As far as we know they would have been, I say it clearly, sold for $10,000 each," said Georg Willeit, who runs the SOS Children's Village outside Port-au-Prince. "That's what one of the policemen told us. Every child was very desperate, hungry, thirsty. They all were in a bad condition."
"One of the elder girls told us, 'I'm not an orphan. I still have my parents,'" he added. "She thought she was going on a summer holiday vacation given by friendly people from America and the Dominican Republic."
The church members, most from Idaho, said they were trying to rescue abandoned and traumatized children. But officials said they lacked the proper documents when they were arrested Friday night in a bus along with children from 2 months to 12 years old who had survived the catastrophic earthquake.
The group said its "Haitian Orphan Rescue Mission" was an effort to help abandoned children by taking them to an orphanage across the border in the Dominican Republic.
"In this chaos the government is in right now we were just trying to do the right thing," the group's spokeswoman, Laura Silsby, told The Associated Press at the judicial police headquarters in the capital, where the Americans were being held pending a Monday hearing before a judge.
No charges had been filed, though Haiti's national secretary for security, Aramick Louis, said a judge had already done a preliminary investigation into the case.
Prime Minister Max Bellerive told The Associated Press Sunday he was outraged by the group's "illegal trafficking of children" in a country long afflicted by the scourge and by foreign meddling.
But the hard reality on the ground in this desperately poor country especially after the catastrophic Jan. 12 quake ח is that some parents openly attest to their willingness to part with their children if it will mean a better life.
It was a sentiment expressed by all but one of some 20 Haitian parents interviewed at a tent camp Sunday that teemed with children whose toys were hewn from garbage.
"Some parents I know have already given their children to foreigners," said Adonis Helman, 44. "I've been thinking how I will choose which one I may give probably my youngest."
[url=http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/35162046/ns/world_news-haiti_earthquake/]Baptist group denies trafficking in Haitian kids - Haiti earthquake- msnbc.com[/url]
It just makes me so sad that parents are in that situation of actually having to think about giving away thier children.
Advertisements
I agree, it's heartbreaking. It's also probably not a decision that should be made while in a refugee camp in the aftermath of a natural disaster. That is why Haiti is and should stop new adoptions for right now.
Sorry but this all sounds way too wrong to me. Whatever their intentions what they did was illegal and they should be prosecuted. Come on the issue of the orphans had been in every paper and on every new program before they left and these people knew that the only children being let out of the country were the ones already in the adoption process or legally with their own families. One story from them says "we thought we had the paper we needed" another says "ok we didn't have all the paper we wanted to save these children." Sorry all I think they saw was a way to made $$$$$$ out of exploiting families.
Nothing sounds right to me and they need to stop hiding behind their religion. They didn't get away with it and I am glad. Help the families do not exploit the families in these times.
Should of said the following in my above post. I think someone in the group was the master mind (for lack of better word) and unfourtantly some others listened and followed this person on this very bad plan. They got pulled into this by listening to the wrong person but still they had to of known something was wrong. These people I can feel somewhat sorry for.
I cannot say with certainty the motives of the workers involved but I have been following this story and and have been able to confirm through multiple sources that:
1) These people had some sort of papers and were in the process of retrieving an additional piece of paperwork in order to cross the border with the children.
2)The children were in bad shape because due to missing paperwork they had to wait outside the police station overnight prior to going back to get whatever paperwork was missing. They were hungry and thirsty and sleepy.
From reading over 21 articles on this situation from different new sources I've come to believe:
A bunch of well-meaning and probably (many) first time missionaries enlisted on an ill advised rescue mission.
They probably promised better lives for all children involved and desperate parents took them up on the offer.
Several folks in this group were college age students and it's probably likely that none of them had an accurate grasp of the politics behind adoptions and child trafficking ect. ect.
I am highly disturbed that the children in question are currently being held at SOS Children's Villages and are not being allowed to see their birth families and may not ever see their birth families again!
Advertisements
I cannot get past the fact that they tried to do this without the paperwork. From what I have read and heard there was going to be NO additional paperwork given the Haitian goverment was NOT allowing children to leave the country unless already in the adoption process or with thier parents.
I agree that some of these people did what they did because they were mislead but it had already been in all the news sources that no children where going to be allowed to leave this country. Even the most evil of people can disguise themselves as well meaning missionaries.
There were other ways to help these families and taking their children with promises of a better life was not one of them. These families are broken and lost.
I am worried about the parents not seeing their children. They need to be reunited and start healing as a family, UMMMM Unicef would be a nice time for you to step forward with some money and help these familes.
I respect what you believe but I just cannot get over the that they tried to do this without the paperwork.
Actually, they did have paperwork but not the correct paperwork. I'm not naive enough to believe that everyone has good intentions and that child trafficking doesn't happen.
I also am aware that the missionaries knew some of these children were not orphans and that parents have come forward and stated on the record that they told these missionaries that their children would starve if they didn't take them and that parents would have surrendered more but there was no room on the bus.
(Associated Press)
Some of these same parents have stated that they do not want to have the kids returned to them because they do not want to watch them starve to death as AID is not getting through in many cases.
There are also other parents who have tried to visit/retrieve their children and those parents have been denied the ability to see their own children
This concerns me.
I think we all can agree that the children are the one's suffering the most through this though.
Just wanted to chime in. Please don't attack the messenger here but I was talking with my mom last night and a friend of hers actually knows someone who was involved with this trip and apparantly they had been preparing this trip for over a year and had been preparing the facility in Dominican Republic (I think that is where they were going) for quite awhile.
I don't know all the story and I don't know all the details but I do know that this wasn't just some people who decided to go down after the earthquakes and "rescue" some children without proper documentation. I just hope all of these children will either go back with their families or somewhere they can all be taken care of.
Not sure how they could have been preparing the facility in the DR when they haven't even purchased the land yet.
Regards,
Dickons
Advertisements
Either way, we all need to pressure these, aid agencies that we have all given money too, to get in there and feed everyone especially the mothers and children...food, medicine, then tents then new homes.
It is pretty clear from the press coverage in the NY Times that the parents of these kids were not giving their children up for ADOPTION by foreigners, they were sending them to live temporarily in a boarding school environment where they would be given food, shelter and an education while their home community lay in ruins.
But if you looked at the website the missionaries had up (I think it may be down now), they were interested in placing these children for adoption abroad.
Very misguided. Bad for all the people who are involved: the children, but also more broadly, all the birthparents and adoptive parents that follow laws could be jeopardized - such incidents are the kind of thing that lead countries to shut down international adoption.
Advertisements
This is the 3rd person who either told me or I read who has posted about the missonaires web site that stated adoption.
This just gives international adoption a bad name. Also once again gives the world another thing to talk about the American Greed.
Just saw on CNN that
"Dominician Rep. has stated they told these people they did not have the paperwork to bring the children into their country."
Wow this is getting worse. Now I wwonder if everyone in the group knew of this. Could everyone in the group been willing to go against the laws of both country.