Advertisements
*edit*
Like
Share
Advertisements
Gosh, I don't want to sound rude, but she sounds like basically a fantastic kid. If I understand your post, she's 17, she goes to school and is going to GRADUATE, she doesn't do drugs or abuse alcohol, and she's got a JOB!! She responsibly pays her portion of the expenses for the car insurance. She apparently only now for the FIRST time has told you she hates you? I thought all teenagers were supposed to say that to their parents at least once a week!
I feel it was a mistake for her punishment to have been decided in the middle of the night. Seems like it would have been better to say you'd talk about it in the morning, and maybe if you were that upset, to have waited a few days to cool off. I mean, she got off work at midnight and only stayed out until 3:30 AM. It doesn't sound like such a terrible crime to deserve a month without a car. I think my punishment for it would be I wouldn't bother to stay up worrying about her next time!
I can understand that as a teenager she is going to overreact, but I don't understand why you are talking about her "throwing everything away", it sounds more like you are throwing her away just because she rebelled a little bit. She's almost 18 and it sounds like you are still treating her like a 16 yr old, I'd say she was due for a little rebellion.
You will probably have more perspective by the time your youngest son is her age, but I hope you don't destroy your relationship with your daughter over an incident. When she says she hates you she most likely means she wants you to give her more freedom and trust.
Maybe you could call her up and say you are planning to go someplace nice for Memorial Day weekend, and you want to know if she wants to come along, or if not, could she be sure and watch the house while you are gone. You know, let her feel like you feel you can depend on her and that of course she is still welcome home.
She stole a car and broke into her parents room. She stayed out 31/2 hours after work with out teling anyone where she was.
Taking the car away from her was not unreasonable. A 17 year old has no business staying out until 3:30 in the morning.
The fact that the daughter chose to leave rather then accept the responsibility for her actions is not the parent's fault.
Just to clarify, no it wasn't the first time she told us that she hated us, to f*uck off, etc. It's whenever we try to set limits. She screams, kicks holes in her doors, walls, writes f*uck you with black marker in huge letters on her bedroom wall...lots of fun stuff.
As far as the car goes, we went out when she got her license and bought a car for her to use because our other vehicle was too big for her to drive. We made it very clear from the start that this was our car, not hers, and that she was to get permission before she took it anywhere. It's scary when your child starts driving! We bought and paid for a cell phone and I asked her to please keep it on whenever she took the car anywhere. From the very beginning she never complied.
We explained that she wasn't listed as primary driver on the insurance in order to keep the cost down, which limited how much she could drive the car, but she never listened to that either. Not to mention that with a provisional license you're not supposed to be driving after midnight anyway. She didn't care, so we made her primary driver and made her pay the difference in the insurance cost. I guess once we did this she decided that the car was hers to do with as she wished, although we continued to tell her otherwise, and that's when the fun began.
Recently we discovered that she's been taking mail addressed to us so we don't see it, (she left school in the middle of the day to go God knows where and got suspended. She forged my name on the notice then spent the days of her suspension at her boyfriend's house) We found the letter along with her forging "practice paper" in the car along with a few traffic tickets that she never bothered to show us either.
There's been a pattern here of not wanting to take responsibilty for her actions.
Yes, she is basically a good kid, as long as everything goes her way and no one tries to set limits for her. Every single time we have tried she has freaked out, and as she has gotten older she has become more and more hateful.
I could almost understand if we were in the habit of handing down harsh punishments and unreasonable requests, but it's not the case. She knew she was supposed to come home right after work. Her father sat up until 3:30 a.m. waiting for her, worrying. She knew we were trying to call her but she decided not to take the call because she didn't want to hear about it. If she wouldn't have completely freaked out we probably would have only taken the car away for a week. And by the way... we didn't talk about this the night it happened. We talked to her the next night, the night before she broke into our bedroom and took the keys and kept the car out all night. When she returned the next morning, that's when I told her what her punishment would be. She reacted by breaking into my bedroom a second time and ransacking it. So too harsh? I don't agree.
I'm sorry, but as I said before, there are two other siblings watching this unfold and I'm not willing to let her run this house, or they may think they can do the same thing.
I do love her, but right now I don't like her very much. If I have to make a decision between her living here and refusing to follow our rules and respect us, or having her live somewhere else, she can live somewhere else. She does nothing around here except eat and sleep, refuses to participate in familiy activities and then she wants to run the place? No. Even a landlord gets more respect.
Originally posted by DenverLiz
Gosh, I don't want to sound rude, but she sounds like basically a fantastic kid. If I understand your post, she's 17, she goes to school and is going to GRADUATE, she doesn't do drugs or abuse alcohol, and she's got a JOB!!
Advertisements
"and if we react to her staying out till 3:00 a.m. by simply "not waiting up and worrying about her next time""
And anyone who thinks it's that easy, has never had to worry about what happened to their child when they didn't return home when expected.
I also do not think you were harsh at all. If she'd lived at my house, I would have reported the car stolen when she broke in my room for the keys.
You are doing what is best for your family. Rules should not be adjusted because the child doesn't like them. Parents are in charge of what behavior is allowed in their house and would be bad parents if they failed to enforce those rules. Her daughter's choice to leave rather then comply is the daughter's choice. Kids do not get to run the house.
Well, it isn't that I don't see that it would be very annoying to have a rebellious teenager, and I don't think rules should be changed just because a child doesn't like them. But I think a person who is almost 18 (and has shown sufficient responsibility to stay in school, have a job, not be doing drugs, etc.) doesn't need a curfew and doesn't need people staying up worrying when it sounds like it is pretty likely she went over to her boyfriends after work, and if so, I can't blame her for not answering the phone. Surely you wouldn't want to be answering calls from her if you were having a romantic interlude?
It just sounds to me like the rules need to be adjusted to be more appropriate to her age. But as the eldest child it is normal that she gets excessively restricted (my brother who is over 50 yrs old still complains how much harder he had it than us younger ones did!).
And don't you think she was quite clever about the suspension from school? I know she wasn't taking responsibility for her actions the way you mean, but she must be a smart and capable kid to intercept the suspension notice, do a good forging job, and just generally avoid getting caught. Ten years from now you two will probably be laughing about it together. (Though I don't mean you should let her see you take it lightly, but it seems like the sort of thing that after she leaves the room you and your husband could laugh about).
Of course, my view is colored by the other teenagers I'm familiar with, who all seem to be so much more trouble that yours really sounds like a dream! My teenage niece simply refuses to go to school at all and keeps trying to commit suicide, my friend's teenager is having problems with depression and for undisclosed (to me) reasons has warrants out for him, another friend's teenage sister has that eating disorder where a person starves themself and she drives her family crazy refusing to eat and fainting, my coworker's teenage boys have kept her going to court practically every month for years to deal with an astounding array of illegal and deliquent activities (and for a while she was having to pay child support to the state for all three of the teenage boys). Her boys make it quite understandable why there was an article in the news that said that on average a woman loses one year of life (dies younger) for each son she has! But even so, I'm sure her boys are going to be very nice young men by the time they get to their mid-twenties.
It sounds like your daughter is going to be a very nice person too, but maybe she'll do lots of crazy things for a couple years before she settles down to college and career.
I get the feeling that you were one of the rare ones who didn't rebel or get into trouble or de-rail for a while when you were a late teenager or young adult?
Personally I think teenagers need to be shipped elsewhere to live, rather than with their families. They are so much better behaved for others than for their own families! My coworker with the three trouble loving boys has reported her kids wind up flourishing in the juvenile system programs they get forced into. One got sent off to some sort of teenage boot camp last year, and before he got taken into custody he was driving his mom crazy, he'd dropped out of high school, didn't have a job, was getting into trouble, etc., and then once he got into enough trouble that the state took over, the program he is in makes the boys have to work real hard and now the kid has become enthused with the idea of joining the airforce when he gets his freedom, and he's working hard toward graduating High School (provided in the boot-camp like program) so he can.
The other son went to some sort of juvenile detention school where there were lots of choices of vocational training and lots of discipline that he actually liked and did well with.
The third son just recently got sucked into the system, and he is off in some wilderness program.
It would be nice if parents could get kids into these programs (for free, just as normal education) without the kids having to break the law a bunch of times first.
Breaking into a room and stealing a car aren't responsible.
Also, a romantic interlude could result in a baby she may not be responsible to care for.
Your views, while very interesting, seem odd to me. My city has curfews for people under 18 because parents aren't giving them to their kids and their kids are causing trouble.
Her daughter does not sound like a "dream" to me. I also paid for my own insurance, my own car, and graduated from high school. However, I treeted my parents with respect and abided by their house rules as long as I lived there and I expect my children to do the same. I would never have ransacked my parents room or even entered it without permission. I would have never taken their car when I was told no(which is theft).
My son won the good citizenship award at school, but he kept trying to kill me and his brother. He'd also made a nice hit list of who he'd like to kill at school. According to the "outside" world, he was also a dream. The fact that someone can complete school and hold a job, does not make them necessarily responsible. Responsible people do not break into other's property and they let people know where they are so they won't worry. Ted Bundy was an excellent student, also.
I'm sure my opinion won't be popular, but I agree with DenverLiz. In a few months your daughter will be a legal adult, and you will have no control or authority over her whatsoever. If you don't feel you can allow her behaviour in your home, then let her (or make her) move out. It sounds like she is testing the limits of your control... let her know the truth, that your control over her is at an end. That it's time for her to learn to control herself, and accept responsibility for the consequences of her own actions. Perhaps by letting go now, you can salvage some sort of relationship in the future. For all intents and purposes, your daughter is an adult. The only real choices you have, as I see it, are to leave her alone and let her do whatever she wants or to evict her from your home (in which case she will still do whatever she wants, but you won't have to know about it, and she won't resent you for your efforts to limit and control her). I mean, really, what other options are there? She's seventeen. You can't tie her up in a closet. I guess you could report her to the police and have her locked up for a few months until she turns 18, but I think this would be really counterproductive in the long run. It would probably only drive her to more rebellion and damage your relationship with her beyond repair. If she's working and going to school, she's doing what she's supposed to do. If her "extracurricular" activities are intolerable to you, tell her to get her own place and drop you a line once in a while. Sincerely, Sharon
Advertisements
If this girl got off work at midnight and been kidnapped or carjacked or worse and the parents had thought she was out goofing off and ignored her failure to return, everyone would be asking why they didn't know where their daughter was.
Eighteen is not some magic age where suddenly a child is able to function as an adult.
I'm really suprised to see that so many people find it acceptable for someone to break into a room, dig through someone's stuff and steal their car.
Sure, the daughter is free to go live elsewhere if she wants to(she's already on her second place in a short period of time which is apparently much smarter then coming home on time).
She cannot, however, steal from her parents(expecially cars).
I guess I just see things differently. In my opinion, respect for other people ranks way ahead of going to school.
My friend who's a therapist often says it"doesn't matter how well a kid does in school if he's flunking life"
Nancy Thomas' says a persons goal in life is to be RESPECTFUL, responsible, and FUN TO BE AROUND.
Originally posted by DenverLiz
But I think a person who is almost 18 (and has shown sufficient responsibility to stay in school, have a job, not be doing drugs, etc.) doesn't need a curfew and doesn't need people staying up worrying when it sounds like it is pretty likely she went over to her boyfriends after work, and if so, I can't blame her for not answering the phone. Surely you wouldn't want to be answering calls from her if you were having a romantic interlude?
Originally posted by DenverLiz
And don't you think she was quite clever about the suspension from school? I know she wasn't taking responsibility for her actions the way you mean, but she must be a smart and capable kid to intercept the suspension notice, do a good forging job, and just generally avoid getting caught.
Originally posted by DenverLiz
I get the feeling that you were one of the rare ones who didn't rebel or get into trouble or de-rail for a while when you were a late teenager or young adult?
Steve
Your daughter sounds very similar to two of ours. THey are now 19 and I am so glad. What some may not realize is that until the child is of legal age, we are considered responsible for them. One always put me in the middle, either her reasons for doing things was to have freedom, but if she didn' t like something, she said I should have taken more control and been tougher. I couldn't win anyway. She wanted to be mad at me.
She used the ploy of blowing up, smashing things, screaming, basically over-reacting, which took the focus off what the original problem was and then put the focus on how "we reacted to her blow-up". We finally got her in a religious residential program until they refused to keep her. We hoped she would be able to do better if the problem was us. She moved in with a family who she put on her sweet act for and totally fooled. When they couldn't take it anymore, she found someone else to take her in. She takes her pattern with her.
IT isn't like it was all horrid. There were good times and we tried to build on that. We kept trying to build responsibility and accountability. However, we were doing all the work. We have had to let her go her way and realize we were a rest stop (an 11 year one) on her journey. We went through false PS reports, much damage to home and cars, and death threats.
I understand some of your feeling right now. We wish no harm to her, but there is no positive relationship to fall back on or build on. It is as if she is addicted to being a victim and tried to get us to be enablers. It is so sad. She is bright and beautiful. However, we can't take anymore of the abuse.
As long as I lived in my parents home, I was required to follow their rules. That is showing respect. So many of the kids today are not taught to respect others and it is showing in our society. My concern would be that until she turns 18 you are responsible for her and if she damages anything or hurts anyone, ultimately you are responsible. I wish you luck.
Felicia
Mom to 4, waiting on one more (ages 22, 14, 13, 9)
Advertisements
Well, since I have to admit I have no real life experience with teenagers (other than having been one 30 years ago) (if the homestudy process would hurry up, maybe I'll have a chance to have real experience before I shuffle off the mortal world), I'll quote from a couple books. I'm sure there are better books to quote, but these are the two (from the library) I happen to have at hand today.
This one is from a book about boys, but I think it probably applies to girls too:
"A sure way for parents and teenagers to get in a muddle with each other is for parents to take what their sons do too personally. Adolescent rebellion is usually directed at parents, because we are the closest authority figures around. Part of our job as parents is to be there to reflect back to our sons who they are ...[snipped, got boring]. Because of this, we feel the brunt of their searching. Most of the time, however, they break the fences [this author calls limits fences] we so carefully built, not to punish us or to get back at us for something we did or didn't do, but because they are motivated by their natural desire to become autonomous. The teenage boy wants to run his own life. He wants to become a man. He finds the weakest links in our fences because he is testing himself just as much as he is testing us.
When a son intentionally or unintentionally breaks the rules of the house, he needs our feedback about how his actions affect the lives of others. Sometimes he needs more pasture to roam in, and other times he needs less. Fences for a teenager can change from day to day. They must be discussed, reevaluated, and shifted to fit, regularly."
"Basic guidelines for setting limits and boundaries with teenagers are:
1. Only set up fences you can enforce.
2. Spend more time in conversation.
3. Be Kind. [I'm too lazy to type in the descriptive paragraphs for each numbered item, so this isn't a complete quote]
4. Always follow through.
5. Choose fences after careful thought.
6. Discussions about fences are best done in private.
7. It is still best that consequences fit the misbehavior.
8. Before setting a consequence, decide what you want to achieve.
9. Sometimes letting the consequences fall naturally where they will is the best trade-off in the end."
I think the original poster's situation was fitting most of the above guidelines, except probably not numbers 2 and 3. That is how it sounded to me anyway.
More quotes:
"Early one morning I discovered that the motor to our Volkswagon was hot. Then our sixteen-year-old son Matt came down to breakfast looking as though he hadn't slept all night. He claimed not to know anything about the car. I figured something was up. On Saturday, I took him to lunch at a favorite place of ours. I confronted him right out. 'Where were you early yesterday morning?' I knew his story was going to be good. He always drives our other car because he can't drive a stick shift, and the Volkswagen Bug is rarely used. Matt hemmed and hawed a bit, and finally spit it out. He had driven ten miles in first gear to his girlfriend's house at 3 a.m. He climbed in her bedroom window on the second floor, made out, got back in the Bug, and couldn't find reverse. He pushed the car into the road, drove home in first gear, turned off the motor, rolled it back into place, and crawled into his bedroom window at 5 a.m. His story had to be the truth, because it was so ridiculous. He had used the Bug because it was parked down the hill, away from the house. All I could say was 'Son, you are one of the most determined and inventive people I have ever known, but please, don't do it again. You could have gotten yourself shot by me, mistaking you for a robber, or by your girl's father, finding out it was you and not a burglar!"
I like the above quote, because it shows a parent not jumping right on a kid about the taking of the car and lying about it, but treating the kid like a likeable person and consequently getting open communication and a chance to make a limit with a bit of humor so it would be listened to without defensiveness.
The above quotes were from a book called 'Raising a Son' by Elium.
The below quote is from the book 'Attaching in Adoption' by Gray. It is not so germaine, but I'm quoting it because in the checklist it points out a few times that teenagers can be bad for a year or two and still be okay.
"Parents' Checklist for Stage VII [that is what they call ages 12 to 19] Emotional Development
1. The teen uses the parent for help when in an emergency.
2. The teen says they love the parent even when they do not need something. Teens may miss a couple years of 'I love you' and still be on-track.
3. The teen shares things about themselves with parents rather than being secretive. Again, there are lapses with teens, but they should not be entirely reclusive.
4. When the teen is sick or hurt, she wants the parents close.
5. The teen feels remorseful if something special of the parent's is ruined. [I find that pretty funny - it doesn't say they avoid ruining it or feel remorseful if it isn't special! Ha! Teenagers!]
6. The teen is usually honest with the parent. Teens may decline to discuss topics, and are cagey, but should not be dishonest. Intrusive parents may contribute to this problem.
7. The teen's value system is individualized from the parent's without being antisocial.
8. The teen thinks of the parent as strong and effective, with no more than one year's lapse.
9. The teen uses the parents or trustworthy peers to calm down when they are distressed.
10. The teen uses the parent's help in gaining knowledge about their world.
11. The teen finds the parent in the house, just to know their whereabouts.
12. The teen feels secure within parent's limits."
I hope this quote (from the same book) is not appropriate, but I think I've read in other books similar stuff about adopted kids having a hard time when they get to age 18, thinking that maybe they won't be a member of the family anymore once they are grown up.
"Later-placed adopted children often need several additional years on the timeline in order to complete their emotional and educational tasks before leaving home. Normalizing this reality throughout the teen years helps teens to think not in terms of age, but in terms of the skill set that they will need in order to leave the home.
It is also helpful to stress the ways in which children will always have their family, pointing out how holidays are celebrated, and describing a family's ongoing help and contact. Histories of abandonment sometimes cause teens to experience vivid feelings of loss as they contemplate leaving home for the first time. Sometimes they want to leave prematurely, getting the loss over with."
Okay last quote for today! From the same book:
"Teens finish Phase VII with an idealized view of what parents and the world should be like. Parents should be perfect. Of course, parents are imperfect, and this is a disappointment which helps them move out of the family home with less regret. By the end of the phase, teens are forming deep friendships with peers."
Denverliz
I had to smile when reading the quotes you sent, as I recalled some of the events of some of our teens. We've been through the 'out until 3am' thing, skipping school just to experience skipping school, dying the hair every possible color with every possible length, and the regular stuff of finding themselves and becoming independent people.
However, some teens( and they don't have to be adopted, but adopted teens often have more baggage to unpack) go to extremes which are not safe. Natural consequences often are not learned from or they get themselves into consequences that they can't get out of. Also, as you said, they oftne mature later, and this means after the legal adult age of 18. This was a rude awakening, because after our duaghter turned 18 and ended up in the hospital on drugs, (I found out because of the insurance authorization fomr sent to us), I couldn't get information because they didn't t know if she had signed an authorization to release infomation to us! You may not even be allowed to parent them after 18. We were told to let her get out and do what ever she wanted. Well, now she is and it is a sad sad, story.
I hope you get the experience of parenting and using your skills and knowledge.
There are certainly kids out there who could benefit.
We used "Parenting with Love and Logic" by Foster Cline and Jim Fay. Lots of good stuff in the book.
Doylene