Advertisements
Hi Kat
Thought I'd put in my 2c worth about the NZ system, since we've just been through it...IT IS VERY SLOW. We started the process in March - got mucked up similarly to you in that a sw put us unto a DAY 1 (we took time off work etc..) then she said it was full and we had to wait 2mths and travel an hour and a half to attend another one. We finally heard we were approved about 3 weeks ago, busted a gut to get our profile in and approved - made some final alterations to it (from the sw suggestions) and two weeks later are still waiting for the official letter to let us know we are in the pool. It certainly tests your patience. Good luck with the process and let me know if you have any questions about it.
Louise
Advertisements
Hi!
I hope you don't mind me butting in -- I'm from the U.S. -- but I was reading another thread last night on Adoption Reform and someone posted an article by an Aussie SW saying what's good about adoption in Australia and wrong with adoption in the U.S. -- and apparently, it's everything. The article went point by point and listed how the Aussie systems worked and why it was better than the U.S. As an adoptive mother myself, I'd be the first to admit our system has flaws, but what really offended me about this article -- and I sincerely hope the author is a loose cannon and doesn't represent general Australian policy -- is that it was virulently anti-adoption. For example, it said that in Australia payments are made to single parents to enable them to care for their children (and we do that, too here in the U.S., through welfare, although the article made it sound like U.S. adoption was all about taking children from the poor and providing them to the rich), that the first priority is to preserve families of origin. It gave an example of an area of Austalia with a million people which had only had one adoption in the past year. Also, it said that older child adoption was too traumatic to children who had already been traumatized. So it's better fo them to have no family ties, at all ?! Basically, the whole article implied adoption was a bad way to create families, rarely done in Australia. I was offended and angry, but it did make me think. It especially disturbs me, if, as someone earlier said, the AUstralian system is held up as a model of "good" adoptions. Do you mind if I ask a few questions? 1) If adoption is so rare, what about families where there's abuse? I know government agencies in the U.S. have been criticized when a child dies and there's been a long pattern of abuse but they've tried to keep the children with their families of origin. 2) What if a parent just doesn't feel ready or able to parent a child? It's not just about money, but lots of other things, like readiness, maturity, etc. Can people NOT put a child up for adoption? 3) Are international adoptions supported? Are they funded through the state? The article said that all costs for domestic adoptions were covered by the state; but if there are so few, it would seem to me that couples wanting to adopt would have to go overseas. Thank you so much for filling me in -- I'm trying to get past my initial knee-jerk reaction to reading this article.
Hi Louise,
you are right, our system sucks if you want to adopt. I'm not saying that people should be forced to give up their children if they are not able to care for them, however I do not agree with the Department of Community Services giving parents as many chances as they want to destroy a child's life. The way it seems to work here is that the child gets fostered indefinately until the parent either decides to get their act together or stays in the system until they are 16 and age out. If there is abuse, the children are taken by DOCS and fostered. The parents can attend parenting classes and anger management classes and get their kids back. Basically, if you want to adopt, you have to go overseas. We do not have older child domestic adoption unless there are particularly extenuating circumstances.
Our welfare system is fantastic compared to a number of other countries. I am a lawyer and have clients who make more on welfare (and have a couple of kids with no dads) than I do (I am quite junior and do legal aid). They also are entitled to almost free travel($2.20 per trip), free medication ($3.00 per prescription) free medical treatment, free education, very cheap all day care for the children plus a parenting allowance. Parents earn more when they have more children, plus our government in a desperate bid for votes in our recent election have brought in a payment of $3000 for the birth of each child. It goes up to $5000 in another 2 years. Why would you give your child up for adoption when you are going to be paid to raise it yourself. Forgive me if i've been ranting about it. It is a touchy subject with me and it is early monday morning (which never helps)
Hi there, from an NZ point of view, we're almost exactly like Australia. And it makes me sick. We have now decided to put adoption on hold, as dh is so angry with the dictatorial system we have here. He had a long talk with our sw this morning, who, thankfully is a great lady, and very open to differing points of view. We have decided to foster, see how we go with that for a while. The foster system is also a laugh (sarcastic). You can only adopt newborns here, as the birth families seem to get chance after chance, and pull the wool over CYFS eyes frequently, hence you get kids abused and murdered by their loving families. Yes, I'm having a rant too!
Better go before I get too mad.
Katrina
wow! foster care! that is going to be tough! I would love to try it but with our system I don't think that I could do it, it is just too unstable for the child. Is NZ the same as Australia? It seems like it is if the parents get heaps of chances. It just makes me sick becasue it is so unfair to the kids. every time they settle in and get on their feet emotionally, DOCS or their parents change their mind about how much contact their is, or throw in another re-unification plan and the kid gets the rug pulled from under them again.
We have a client who has a 12year old who is in the system. he's had 16 long term placements break down since he was 5 and only in the last month has DOCS told the mother to make up her mind if she wants him or not. She has decided not, but he is not available for adoption. He is just in care until he is 16 then he will be without a family as his fosters probably won't keep him and his birth family is not interested. it makes me sick to see how the mother has had 7 years to come to this decision and now the kid is virtually a right-off.
All the very best luck with your venture into foster care... i hope it works out really well for you katrina
Advertisements
Ohhhhh, yes!! Much as we Aussies and Kiwis like to knock the lights out of each other, so much is similar with our govt policy. It is sick making that a child can be so mucked around for so long, then when they really start to stuff up as an adult, the finger pointing starts. We've come up with a bit of a philosophy (dh and I) about fostering. That's if we even get through, he is so mad at CYFS and I wouldn't put it past the adoption unit to let the foster unit know it! We have decided that we will care for babies under 12-18mths, for whatever periods of time, when they come to us we will love them, when they leave us we will enjoy having our home and our family back to ourselves. Sounds a bit selfish, but we're trying to make a difference and protect ourselves at the same time. You never know, we may get a "keeper" or two!! Do I sound REALLY callous? Surely somewhere, on some level, those tiny babes will have a memory imprint of the people who loved them for a little while...
Katrina
Hi
I live in Australia with my husband and have an adopted son from Thailand. We are also in the process of adopting our second, again from Thailand - our file in is Thailand awaiting allocation, but it will be quite some time yet. The first time the process seemed onerous and quite daunting ,but now that I have my son I understand that the process is there for a reason - to protect children and also the applicants as adopting a child from another country has a huge impact on your lives. The second time around I found the process quite simple and not at all daunting - I think I was more confident and also knew what to expect. That is not to say that the process is good as I think more could be done to make the process smoother and quicker.
What I do find frustrating about adopting internationally in Australia is that states often handle things differently eg for Thai adoptions residents in South Australia can use an adoption agency which will have links with various orphanages like Red Cross, whereas in Qld you must go through the Dept of Communities and then the Dept of Social Development & Welfare in Thailand.
In one of the posting someone mentioned that adoption of older children is not permitted in Australia - I don't know about local adoptions but for overseas adoptions the Dept of Communities prefers not to put forward applications for children over 5 y.o. however, this can & has been challegned successfully.
I'd be interested to hear from anyone who knows about Thai adoptions in South Australia as the support group I belong to is trying to get more information together on this topic.
Julie
Advertisements
We have thought about fostering but we haven't actually done anything more about it, yet. Just not sure we can deal with the giving up a child we are attached to! Yes the pain of been in the "pool" is sometimes really difficult to live with, but given the choices.....its not bad. (choices meaning NOT being in the "pool".
Have you fostered??
cheers,
Judy
Advertisements