Advertisements
My husband I just received a bill for legal and living expenses for the birthmother who we supported for 6months. The adoption failed after we had him for a month. Leading up to the birth, the birthmother's lawyer lost paperwork, failed to return calls, and caused lots of problems. Does anyone have any experience/advice with receiving post-failed adoption bills for services that were rendered prior to the failure? We think that our support of her was contingent on the arrangement for her to place her child with us and given that this relationship has terminated, we should not be held responsible for the fees that were incurred that we were not previously billed for. i am sure i sould detached and focused too much on the money but I just don't think its fair!
Like
Share
bromanchik
The thing is that you chose to pay those expenses. You did not have to. There are many expectant parents that do not require or ask for expenses. If you do not wish to pay them, just say no.
Advertisements
oceanica
I'd like to officially apologize to all emoms and bmoms out there.
I made that comment the day after I was told by my agency that I was scammed for 2100 dollars. It was my first day here and I was noticing all the other posters with dates and disruptions listed, and I made an incredibly rude and unfair remark. Even if I hadn't been scammed it would have been difficult to go through the failed match and I was completely unprepared for some reason. I wish I had been more cautious and thought harder about all eventualities.
At any rate I know better than to stereotype so no excuses, it was a stupid thing to say and I hope nobody felt bad because of it.
Really the bottom line is that the whole system is very flawed. I just wish there was a solution. Believe me, I will do something about it if I come up with one.Meanwhile, we also just had a failed placement after supporting the birthmother for 6 months. Luckily our 3 year-old (through foster care) keeps us from being too sad about it. In response to the people that said "you can choose what situations to pursue". That is very true, but after 5 years of trying to adopt privately w/no "hits", we were stuck with having spent thousands of dollars with an attorney and facilitator that we never thought were doing their job. Then when a birthmother was FINALLY interested in us, we follow the advice of the PROFESSIONALS and OTHER prominent adoption attorneys, and decide to match w/someone we were never totally comfortable with. The situation kept getting more and more expensive... you feel very helpless and that if you don't continue with this situation there might not be another one. Yes, we could have quit but at that point we'd come so far and everyone said "oh it's only 1 more month, it's only a few more weeks... she's definitely going to place, she can't take care of herself, let alone a baby. In our situation, the birthfather came into the picture at the last minute and in our opinion pressured the bmom to keep the baby. I can only hope that something changes in their situation because that poor baby isn't going to have a very good start in life.I don't trust anyone in the adoption triad right now and we're not sure we'll be trying again.
Oceanica - just wanted to say that I thopught it was really cool of you to apologize like that - and very cool of all of you offended to accept so graciously.
And I have to say - this is one of the reasons why you guys need to elect someone who supports universal health care! And yes, I do realize I am COMPLETELY sticking my nose in where it doesn't belong. But seriously, these things would all be moot - all pregnant women, no matter what their income, education, race, socio-economic status would have access to FREE health care...I am always amazed at people opposing this - I just don't get it. But maybe that is a whole new thread :flower: Or, you could all just move to Canada :clap:
Hello to all, I have followed this post and as usual have appreciated all views...one reason I keep coming back, all of you are makiong me so much smarter..LOL! As some of you know , I am a Firstmom, relinquished twin sons,1986. I never once was told ANYTHING about expenses. Some of you may ask how does one know who pays what? I was just following what my SW wanted me to do. She weekly bought lunch, supper, my 6 yr old gifts,payed for maternity clothes, utilities,rent,and also informed me that all of my expenses were to be paid for 3 months after I relinquished my twins..."to give me time to heal and get back to work". Fast forward...When it was my last night with twins I called SW and told her I had changed my mind, that I wanted to parent my sons...ALL HELL hit the fan! I was threatened into possibly losing my 6 yr old, told twins would not be ALLOWED to leave the hospital with me, they would be placed into foster care until ALL bills were paid, then a judge would have to decide if I was fit to parent my twins and possibly be questioned on my ability to raise my 6 yr. old. I do not know if the parents of my twins were behind this or if they were as clueless as I....I do know I DID NOT ASK for anything that accrued during my pregnancy. I freaked out thinking "oh My GOD, they are gonna take my 6 yr old...they will put my twins into foster care...WHAT AM I GONNA DO?" You guessed it ..I was a coward and believed them, I signed those papers! SO MY QUESTION IS OF SIMPLICITY..."Who Really Pays The Price?" I am SOOOO ashamed of my cowardness and stupidity!
Advertisements
Sorry for my rant the other day...I get very emotional when it comes to expenses. I guess my point I was gonna make was, the Mother was not pushed into changing her mind by the father of her baby. I would bet the farm, she changed her mind ,because she loves her baby and wanted to parent, with or without the father, it made no difference to her. She made the right choice and parents wishing to adopt need to be fully aware that these decisions will happen. I fully believe that when one chooses to adopt a newborn infant , one needs to have an agreement up front and know all possible outcomes, long with total expenses. I would think if one truly has to worry about finances, then maybe one should consider a "cheaper" form of adoption(foster/orphaned). Just my opinion! I think the reason newborns are such a "commodity" is because it is BIG money! This saddens me to read about these outcomes, biased or not, I will always root for the Mom to parent, after all that is the way it is meant to be....:flower:
I agree that these posts make us all smarter, b/c we can see or learn about someone else's perspective. What I will say, is I will never assume that I understand the pain that a firstmother goes through in deciding to place her baby. I am horrified about the accounts of mothers being lied to and pressured into placement. However, to say that prospective adoptive parents should choose a "cheaper" option like fostercare is to disregard the deep desire of those PAPs to be parents and to have a healthy experience. Fostercare is also full of the same risks. Often families can bring children home for months, even years without a guarantee of permanency. As the person who started this thread months ago and has begun to move on from our failed adoption, I will answer your original question- who pays? everyone! I respect the rights of firstparents but need for you to know that our world was shattered and money was not the central issue. We had spent five months supporting her financially and emotionally. We travelled out of state to attend dr. appts, heard the heartbeat, decorated the nursery and even brought him home from the hospital. I won't bother listing the symptoms of my subsequent depression but I promise you that I will never be the same. We love that little boy so much. Just as I can never understand your pain, please don't presume to understand mine or to trivialize it. The money issue comes from now that we want to start the process over, we don't have the resources to do it.
MLS0915, I am sorry you felt I trivialized your feelings...and yes your post WAS about finances. I understand wanting to be a parent and also becoming ATTACHED and loving a baby..then gone the next instance. No I did not have my twins for 1 or 2 months, then poof, have them be snatched from me....NO that did not happen to me, I had my twins for 9 MONTHS AND 4 DAYS AND 18 HOUR5S, before I was THREATENED by people who were willing to destroy my life with my twins AND my 6 yr old. So no maybe I cannot understand your personal pain for the short amount of time you had, but DO NOT trivialize my plight of having spent 9 months with my twins , then coerced into relinquishment....over FINANCES! Your journey is one that is long and at times heart crushing, but the next one you decide to fall in love with...imagine bonding with the child for 9 months, then have them yanked away...just imagine. I am very sympathetic to you yearning to be a Mom, just be aware that when you go forward that it really isn't about who pays the expenses (i.e.finance), its about two women whom just want whats best for a baby...LOVE! GODS Blessings.....:flower:
Guys - this discussion has taken a turn none of want to see happen (I think).
The truth is, ALL sides of the triad experience deep pain and hurt - how can we say "my pain is greater than yours"? What will that accomplish?
Cetalley - I am truly sorry to hear about your situation, and I can't even imagine the pain you are dealing with. But please know, most adoptive parents also believe the first choice for the child is with his/her birth family. But saying things like "I cannot understand your personal pain for the short amount of time you had" and making sounds as though your pain is greater due to time you had with your babies doesn't help anyone, least of all - yourself. As you well know, it is not amount of time spent with a baby that makes you fall in love. Is a parents grief when a baby dies of SIDS at 2 months less valid than a parents who lose a child at 6 months? Of course not.
Let's just acknowledge there is pain on all sides - equally. And every situation is different - not all babies are snatched from their birth mom. And I agree with you - while money is something that has motivated very unethical situations - they are a reality.
Advertisements
KarynB, I digress, what you said is nothing less than the truth. I was simply trying to let MLS0915, that I was not trivializing her journey...in no way, shape or form. Her original post was about the expenses and final bills...(ie.money). I do not expect any one to shoulder my blame, just know that when you are going into an adoption journey, that EVERYTHING be put into writing and understand that the adoption may not go through. I agree as with all the triad...the BEST thing is for a child to stay with its Mom, if that is what the mom wants. She should never be looked at less a person for wanting to love her child. I do get to ranting too much when it gets to any one whom brings up the unfairness of having to pay bills, when in the beginning of their journey, they should have been fully aware of all the expense, including the adoption falling through. So, I apologize if anyone took offense to my opinion, as I did not mean to TRIVIALIZE anyones feelings. Have a great day to ALL!:grouphug:
dragonflylady
A couple of thoughts:
First, whoever said its a "donation" I completely disagree. As an adoptive parent, you sign an agreement with your attorney that holds you responsible for paying the expenses. I dont call that a donation.
It used to be that a birthmom just wanted to place a child with a good family. Now its all about earning the most expenses and being protected by law from having to do the right thing and return the money.
With my failed adoption, the birthparents both worked and had medical insurance. But I still had to pay for food, utlities, gas, rent, maternity clothes and to fix their car.
If the roles were reversed, I would be making payments, even if they were just $10 a week, to the adoptive parents as appreciation for ensuring that while I was pregnant I was never hungry, cold, without shelter or transportation.
I feel most for adoptive families that put themselves into debt to adopt, and who had only one chance at making this happen financially - and they have nothing to show for it and no one that cares.
I won't tell you that you shouldn't be bitter. You wouldn't be human if you weren't bitter. You are hurting. You have been lied to. You have lost two possible children, and you are very worried that one of them is in an unloving, maybe abusive situation and you can't do anything about it.I don't know how to tell you to cope. I won't say "to get over it" because you won't. These losses are imprinted in your life experience. They will make you tougher, and wiser, and ultimately they will help you make decisions for your future.
Advertisements
Interesting post. Lots of things to think about. We are all in pain and will be for the rest of our lives. I feel for everyone involved in this discussion.
Please DO NOT TAKE OFFENSE AT MY POST- I do not mean to offend emoms who ask for expenses.
It took us much longer to adopt than normal because we REFUSED to pay for a baby. Many of the cases we were presented with wanted 8000-10000 in expenses not including medical or legal. Being pregant USUALLY does not make you unable to support yourself you may need help but not 8000-10000 worth. We had several failed matches, did not loose much money, because we went into adoption to adopt a baby not buy, so we were very careful with what expenses we would pay. We were finally matched and agreed to pay around $3000 in expenses not including medical, (Still waiting on final medical bills). This was reasonable because of a c-section that made it impossible for the young mom to return to work as quickly as she wanted, and she needed to be able to support her other children.
Matching early and paying expenses is a risk you choose to take. Giving birth, placing a child and receiving a child is emotional and when emotions are high, you never know what will happen.
I do feel for everyone who has lost money due to minds being changed, but they do have a right to change minds. I am mad at every bmom who intentionally scams, it happens, I wish it could be prevented.
jp4, good for you, it makes me happy to know you have ever so wisely decided up front , what you would and would not do. Congratulations on your child, I am so happy when moms whom have waited, knowing all the expectations, finally get a chance to be a mom. I feel that every woman whom desires nothing more than to be a Mom , deserves to be! I can only hope my twins have morally kind , honest, loving, compassionate parents, and to know they are safe, together, and healthy. A part of me died 22 yrs ago, so hoping that GOD will one day allow me to know that what I endured was for nothing! Again congrats on being a Mom, I am sure you are amazing at that. :flower: