Advertisements
Advertisements
When reading these forums and comments on other forums/blogs/articles, I do get the impression that many people misunderstand what an adoptee may mean when they say “I wish I had never been adopted”.
I can’t speak for others but what I would mean if I said that above quote is" “I wish I had been born and raised in the ONE family”. This is where the misunderstanding often rises because many people assume that those who say that quoted sentence mean their specific biological family whereas they are saying exactly what they said, i.e. they wish they wish they had been born and raised in the ONE family, not any specific family but just the one family.
The family we wished we had born and raised in may consist of the following:
1. our biological family
2. our adoptive family
3. a mixture of either family
4. a totally different family
5. Brangelina or other movie stars lol
6. any other family we know IRL
7. we may not have the faintest idea
For those who have been born and raised in a functional family, their nature and nurture is seamlessly combined so that you can’t tell where one starts and the other finishes.
For those people who have been born into one family and raised in another, the nature and nurture are separated, even open adoptions can't totally overcome that fact. Many of us adoptees became adaptees and adapt. Some of us will always treasure only our nurture side, some of us want to know more about the nature side.
For those of us in closed adoption making contact with our nature side, it can be extraordinarily hard trying to figure it all out which is why reunions often go south. Many of us are trying to work out the nature/nurture dynamics and it can be hard.
It is not unlike how it is for a person born in one country eg A and raised in another, eg B. They may love growing up in B but may want to know more about A and may consider themselves to be of both A&B. Most of us would (hopefully) not tell them that they shouldn’t be interested in A or that they should be grateful for growing up in B – it is not up to other people to tell them that. Whether or not a person is interested in knowing about country A is their decision – no-one else should be telling them that. However, we adoptees are told all the time what we are supposed to feel about each family and it is no-one else’s business but our own.
I wish the situation that created the necessity for adoption for me had never happened. I wish my father wouldn't have died when my mother was pregnant. I wish my siblings wouldn't have been robbed of the knowledge of me. Yep, my older siblings didn't even know about me until I was in my mid 20's.
I've never been angry about being adopted, I have been angry about the situation my mother was in though.
Advertisements
belleinblue1978
I wish the situation that created the necessity for adoption for me had never happened. I wish my father wouldn't have died when my mother was pregnant. I wish my siblings wouldn't have been robbed of the knowledge of me. Yep, my older siblings didn't even know about me until I was in my mid 20's.
I've never been angry about being adopted, I have been angry about the situation my mother was in though.
Hi Belle. I started this thread because I revisited an old thread in which many of us adoptees were trying to make a point but people kept saying "but our child loves us and wants us to be our only family" and I just felt that what they were saying was just proving what we were trying to say.
Your story of being relinquished because your bfather died before you were born is so sad. If you don't mind my asking, how did your mother hide her pregnancy from your siblings? I hope I am not being too insensitive.
My main pain comes from not knowing the answer to so many questions because of my bmom's untimely death. Even though evidence points towards my bmother having genuinely done what she felt was best for her child given the circumstances, times and mores, I have no real idea whether she would have raised me if circumstances were different. Based on what evidence I have, I get the impression as long as her pregnancy was a secret, I was always going to be relinquished but if her parents had visited her overseas where she was living, saw she was pregnant and said that they wanted her to come home, she would have gone and probably been relieved that her secret was out. Of course that is all assumption only, I may be totally off base. Just the fact that I have no idea how she felt after the adoption is hard to deal with though I am slowly getting there. I am only a year and a half into reunion after all, it will take time.
Caths you hit the nail on the head with this one!
I wish I wasn't adopted is a painfully yet reoccuring thought in my head.
Only because I wish I could look at someone that resembles me, and if my Aparents were my biological parents there wouldn't be questions about medical history, or what my 1st mom looks like because I would have seen her every day of my life.
I wouldn't wonder who fostered me for 3 months, or why my 1st father was raised by his grandmother. I would be 1/2 German 1/4 AA and 1/4 some more CC lol!
So there would be no digging into my Japanese heirtage
I wouldn't wonder where my DD got her dimple from, and maybe some other family members wouldn't have snubbed their noses at the "adopted black sheep" I'd just be the "black sheep" lol!
But you're right Caths, we don't say it to be hurtful to our familes (well some do) I just want all of the answers, and lack of answers makes any one crazy!
BabyRachelVA
Caths you hit the nail on the head with this one!
I wish I wasn't adopted is a painfully yet reoccuring thought in my head.
Only because I wish I could look at someone that resembles me, and if my Aparents were my biological parents there wouldn't be questions about medical history, or what my 1st mom looks like because I would have seen her every day of my life.
I wouldn't wonder who fostered me for 3 months, or why my 1st father was raised by his grandmother. I would be 1/2 German 1/4 AA and 1/4 some more CC lol!
So there would be no digging into my Japanese heirtage
I wouldn't wonder where my DD got her dimple from, and maybe some other family members wouldn't have snubbed their noses at the "adopted black sheep" I'd just be the "black sheep" lol!
But you're right Caths, we don't say it to be hurtful to our familes (well some do) I just want all of the answers, and lack of answers makes any one crazy!
Thanks BabyRachel :)
I wish you had all the answers too! How is the search going? Do they let you know what they have found or are you kept in the dark? If your CI is not finding anything, can they pass on any of the info? I am not sure how it all works.
I know I am very lucky living in Ausralia/NZ where we have had access to our records from late 80s/early 90s and I feel so much for those of you in the US who aren't allowed your OBCs. Even though I will never know all the answers either, that is mainly due to sad circumstances and I do at least know most of what I can know (hope that makes sense lol). My lovely extended bfamily have been very kind and welcoming and I couldn't ask for more in that regards.
Advertisements
caths1964
I can’t speak for others but what I would mean if I said that above quote is" “I wish I had been born and raised in the ONE family”.
What a great post! As an amom I totally understand what you are saying...and I wish it for my daughter as well, even though of course, she couldn't be my daughter and have that be true...right now she is young and she already wishes it. She wishes I had her in my tummy. I expect that one day she'll wish it another way, and that will be that she never left her birthmom...and another day she will wish Brangelina :) But it makes so much sense...all part of the desire for ONE.
thank you.
Susan
Suzeb1
What a great post! As an amom I totally understand what you are saying...and I wish it for my daughter as well, even though of course, she couldn't be my daughter and have that be true...right now she is young and she already wishes it. She wishes I had her in my tummy. I expect that one day she'll wish it another way, and that will be that she never left her birthmom...and another day she will wish Brangelina :) But it makes so much sense...all part of the desire for ONE.
thank you.
Susan
I really appreciate you saying that, Susan. I think you sound like a very understanding person and I think you have a lucky daughter :)
You know, I have probably said these words thousands of times during my 40 years. Sure, sometimes I said it as a teen "meaning" I wish a different set of parents adopted me because I wasn't getting what I wanted and was being reactionary and as a child, staying with my natural parents was never really something I thought about even being possible.
The way I now know that I really feel when I say "I wish I was never adopted" has nothng to do with my parents - either adoptive or natural. I wish the situation didn't happen and I wouldn't have to have dealt with the adoptive issues.
This is probably your exact same point caths, but just thought I would echo it.
Jonathan
The search has gone cold sadly and I know its not for lack of trying, Michelle sounds exhausted with my search, poor dear.
But I can say the urgent longing feeling has faded for now. I've noticed in the past when I thought I needed something it never happened. And when I started accepting how things were and just allowing myself to be 100% fufilled with my life and letting myself be happy, good unexpected amazing things happen.
So as of right now I'm working on me. Maybe right now isn't the right time for us to find each other, but I believe we will.
(and if it takes too long, my obsessive search is taking me to VA to petition the courts to release my OBC lol)
caths1964
Thanks BabyRachel :)
I wish you had all the answers too! How is the search going? Do they let you know what they have found or are you kept in the dark? If your CI is not finding anything, can they pass on any of the info? I am not sure how it all works.
I know I am very lucky living in Ausralia/NZ where we have had access to our records from late 80s/early 90s and I feel so much for those of you in the US who aren't allowed your OBCs. Even though I will never know all the answers either, that is mainly due to sad circumstances and I do at least know most of what I can know (hope that makes sense lol). My lovely extended bfamily have been very kind and welcoming and I couldn't ask for more in that regards.
Advertisements
jking1118
You know, I have probably said these words thousands of times during my 40 years. Sure, sometimes I said it as a teen "meaning" I wish a different set of parents adopted me because I wasn't getting what I wanted and was being reactionary and as a child, staying with my natural parents was never really something I thought about even being possible.
The way I now know that I really feel when I say "I wish I was never adopted" has nothng to do with my parents - either adoptive or natural. I wish the situation didn't happen and I wouldn't have to have dealt with the adoptive issues.
This is probably your exact same point caths, but just thought I would echo it.
Jonathan
Thanks Jonathan, you got the point exactly :)
I was trying to put it in a way that APs would understand because as you remember from that thread I told you about, there did seem to be a misunderstanding.
Btw I thought you might like the following blog. Even though she is an IA, a lot of her feelings resonate with how many adoptees, especially those in reunion, feel (it is worth reading a lot of her older posts).
[url=http://yoonsblur.blogspot.com/2011/06/i-take-it-personally.html]Yoon's Blur: I take it personally[/url]
BabyRachelVA
The search has gone cold sadly and I know its not for lack of trying, Michelle sounds exhausted with my search, poor dear.
But I can say the urgent longing feeling has faded for now. I've noticed in the past when I thought I needed something it never happened. And when I started accepting how things were and just allowing myself to be 100% fufilled with my life and letting myself be happy, good unexpected amazing things happen.
So as of right now I'm working on me. Maybe right now isn't the right time for us to find each other, but I believe we will.
(and if it takes too long, my obsessive search is taking me to VA to petition the courts to release my OBC lol)
I've noticed that too!
I believe you will find each other too (((hugs)))
Has Michelle been able to provide you with any information or is she keeping it all to herself?
Maybe you should become a CI and do your own search lol (OK, I know it doesn't work like that lol)