Advertisements
Advertisements
Hello everyone. I haven't been on here in ages, but really wanted to vent about something that happened yesterday.
Background: I have been involved with the agency that facilitated the relinquishment of my son for some time now in attending their support groups. I can honestly say, these meetings have been a big help to me as I was going through the reunion process, in particular hearing other people's stories, both first parents and adoptees (and occasionally we have adoptive parents attending as well) and also getting individual support from the woman who handles search and reunion. While I have major issues with agencies in general, and some with mine in particular, overall, the post-adoption and reunion services they have provided have been very good. Another major reason I like to attend these groups is because I have a strong desire to meet with other first moms (sometimes we get dads, too) in person, and help them navigate the reunion process, as so many others were there for me throughout my own emotional roller-coaster ride.
The agency also sponsors a Birthmother's Day brunch every year, which I have attended a number of times in past years. Even though I have mixed feelings about the whole day (and I celebrate Mother's Day just like any other mother), I like to go to talk to the other first moms, enjoy a nice meal, and again, give and receive support. These events are usually very nicely done and well-organized, and of course, they are emotional, too, but overall I have found them to be handled in a very sensitive way.
This year's brunch was held yesterday, and I had the honor of having a very good friend accompany me, who is in the very early stages of searching for her son. This was her first time at any sort of agency meeting. After we were going through group introductions, the director of the maternity department (or whatever it's called, this is the woman who handles adoptions, not the post-adoption search & reunion worker who typically runs these events by herself), wanted to give a "speech." In this speech, she told us the agency was celebrating it's 100th anniversary this year, and went on about all the services they provide and how we have all benefitted from these services, and if any of us were interested in "giving back" we could (and only if we wanted to, of course, it wasn't mandatory) have our photos taken at the brunch, and "share our stories" to be used in their promotional materials (release forms to be provided, of course). Needless to say, I was horrified.
I turned to the post-adoption worker and motioned her to come over. I expressed that I thought the whole spiel being given by the director was in very bad form, and she looked at me puzzled. I said I would talk to her about it later, but decided not to broach the subject at the event. When we had a break, I spoke to my friend, who said she was really put off by this whole marketing speech, and I told her my feelings on the whole thing as well. I did approach the director and told her under no circumstances did I want my photo taken at the event, any of my words recorded or used for any reason, and she said that was fine, but still, I felt uneasy about this woman even being there in the first place the whole rest of the afternoon.
There were two or three first moms who were all gung-ho about having their photos taken and "telling their stories" and while I respect that for some, perhaps they feel the agency really was "there for them" and their experiences were good, I and my friend were quite upset that after going through the loss of our children, we should be asked to be shills for the agency in order to "give back" to them. Haven't we given enough?
And to do this on a special day dedicated to us as birth/first mothers was especially insensitive, from my perspective.
I cannot help but wonder on this "100th anniversary" if the agency is not in desperate need for babies, thus the aggressive soliciting of a captive audience of first mothers to tell other women how wonderful the agency was to them in their "time of need." And I GET that they are an agency, a business, essentially, and as such, they want to put "positive stories" out there. And that some women are fine with that and willing to do it. BUT. Could they not have solicited people individually, either through a phone call or an email? And I don't know if I'm over-thinking this, but it also felt very coercive to me to do it as part of our brunch, while we were all there feeling very emotional and some of us even vulnerable, like my friend, who was there for the first time.
Anyway, I was just needing to get this off my chest and any feedback in terms of what I should say in my letter would be appreciated.
Peachy, I was just thinking about you the other day when I was reading an old thread...
As an adoptee I think it is terribly inappropriate to ask a mother to promote adoption to an expectant mother. If adoption is the right choice then that will be the choice. If not, other mothers promoting it might just sway some who may not have needed to chose adoption. Having said that, it does seem to be a trend happening - newer mothers jumping on the band wagon about how adoption is the best thing ever, it does give me pause because I view it through an adoptee mind, and a mother whose child passed away - and can't imagine seeing loosing your baby as a positive do it again choice.
Perhaps you need to tell them that you would not be comfortable promoting adoption because it is only once it is too late, can you really start to understand the sheer amount of grief and life-long pain that comes with being a first mother.
Personally, being rather snarky - I'd inquire if they have a dual campaign going, and, are asking adoptive parents if they get pregnant with their miracle baby to consider "paying it forward" and placing that baby for adoption so another couple can also have the joys of parenting...
Kind regards,
Dickons
Advertisements
JustPeachy
In this speech, she told us the agency was celebrating it's 100th anniversary this year, and went on about all the services they provide and how we have all benefitted from these services, and if any of us were interested in "giving back" we could (and only if we wanted to, of course, it wasn't mandatory) have our photos taken at the brunch, and "share our stories" to be used in their promotional materials (release forms to be provided, of course). Needless to say, I was horrified.
I'm not surprised you were horrified. "Giving back"? What a cheek.
(((((Peachy)))))
Long time no see, my friend. You were right to be horrified -- I would have come unglued if I had been in your shoes. I hate it when the big agencies use birth/first moms as marketing material. I totally detest the practice, which seems common among the large agencies that have been around forever. Many of the agencies put these "birth mother" satisfaction stories on their websites, and I always feel like gagging when I see a woman who tore her heart out to give her baby a better chance at life be used as a tool to convince other expectant mothers to part with their babies.
It's wrong on so many levels...just plain wrong.
Dickons
Personally, being rather snarky - I'd inquire if they have a dual campaign going, and, are asking adoptive parents if they get pregnant with their miracle baby to consider "paying it forward" and placing that baby for adoption so another couple can also have the joys of parenting...
Snarks aside I find both campaigns horrific. I see no reason for any mother to have to part with her child unless there is absolutely no other option. That should be the campaign. There is clearly enough adoptions happening to enable them to be successful for 100 years....
I see no reason for them to as Peachy suggested to promote participation in this advertisement in such an event. Clearly they could have reached out to placing parents individually. I too find it insensitive. I would have been very upset and I probably would have said something too.
I'm sorry that your friend had her first experience turn so negative. Clearly your agency has done well after placement. I'm thrilled to hear they offer support groups and do events. I hope your friend gives it another chance but I'd make it clear to the agency that any "pro placement propaganda" should be done at another place another time (or never)....
Gah, because giving them your only child wasn't enough? You need to do more for them?
I'd like to say I'm surprised, but I'm not. Anything to make a buck for these agencies which is a sad commentary on adoption in this country.
It seems like some people think we will never quit owing doesn't it?
Advertisements
Hello to "old" friends (yes, I'm still the old one!) Peachy, I'm trying to think what I would write (and who I could send copies to so they couldn't bury it!) I would probably be sure to tell them how much their support has helped as you searched for, found, and reunited with your son. I would say that I can't begin to tell them how inappropriate I found the speech at the only day set apart for "birth" mothers.
I know that I came out of the BSE but the only use I had for an agency was to find an appropriate couple to adopt my son. I had no contact with them before or after the adoption and that's fine with me!
How are all you. I am home recovering from surgery (look up gall stone illius) The good news is I'm doing well. (My husband forgot to include D when he told the kids and I got a shocked text from him... )